Describe the financial relations between the Centre and States in India.

Points to Remember:

Constitutional provisions regarding financial relations.
Sources of state revenue.
Mechanisms for central assistance.
Issues and challenges in the system.
Recommendations for improvement.

Introduction:

India operates a federal system where the Centre and States share governmental responsibilities. A crucial aspect of this federal structure is the financial relationship between them, governed primarily by the Constitution of India. Article 265 of the Constitution prohibits the Union and the States from levying taxes except as authorized by the Constitution. However, the distribution of financial resources between the Centre and States has been a subject of continuous debate and reform since independence. The initial arrangement, heavily tilted towards the Centre, has evolved through various Finance Commissions and constitutional amendments, yet challenges persist.

Body:

1. Constitutional Provisions:

The Constitution outlines the division of tax powers between the Centre and States. The Union List, State List, and Concurrent List specify taxes that can be levied by the Centre, States, and both, respectively. The Union enjoys greater taxing powers, particularly in areas like customs, excise, and income tax, generating significantly more revenue. States primarily rely on sales tax (now GST), stamp duty, and land revenue. The Finance Commission, established under Article 280, plays a crucial role in recommending the principles governing the distribution of tax revenue between the Centre and the States.

2. Sources of State Revenue:

State revenues are derived from various sources:

State Taxes: These include GST (shared with the Centre), stamp duty, land revenue, state excise duties, and taxes on motor vehicles.
Grants-in-aid from the Centre: These are provided to states based on the recommendations of the Finance Commission, aimed at equalizing resource availability and promoting development. These grants can be general or specific, earmarked for particular projects or schemes.
Share in Central Taxes: The Finance Commission recommends the share of central taxes (like income tax and excise duty) to be distributed among the States. This is a crucial component of state finances.
Other Sources: These include loans, market borrowings, and state-owned enterprises.

3. Mechanisms for Central Assistance:

The primary mechanism for central assistance is through the recommendations of the Finance Commission. The Commission’s recommendations cover:

Distribution of net proceeds of taxes: This involves determining the share of central taxes to be allocated to the States.
Grants-in-aid: These are provided to states to meet their expenditure needs and reduce fiscal disparities. These grants can be revenue grants (for general purposes) or capital grants (for specific development projects).
Special grants: These are provided to states facing exceptional financial difficulties or for specific developmental purposes.

4. Issues and Challenges:

Vertical Imbalance: A significant disparity exists between the revenue-raising capacity of the Centre and the States, leading to dependence of states on central transfers.
Horizontal Imbalance: Disparities in resource availability exist among different states due to variations in economic development and population.
Fiscal Federalism: The system’s effectiveness in promoting fiscal federalism, i.e., a balance of power and resources between the Centre and States, is often debated.
Conditionalities attached to grants: Central grants sometimes come with conditions that may restrict the autonomy of states in utilizing funds.
Delayed transfers: Delays in the transfer of funds from the Centre to the States can hamper state-level development initiatives.

Conclusion:

The financial relations between the Centre and States in India are complex and constantly evolving. While the Finance Commission plays a vital role in ensuring a relatively equitable distribution of resources, challenges remain in achieving a truly balanced fiscal federalism. Addressing the vertical and horizontal imbalances, streamlining the grant allocation process, and minimizing conditionalities attached to central assistance are crucial for strengthening the federal structure. Promoting greater transparency and accountability in the allocation and utilization of funds is also essential. Moving forward, a more flexible and responsive system that empowers states while ensuring national cohesion is needed. This requires continuous dialogue, collaboration, and a commitment to upholding the principles of cooperative federalism, ensuring holistic development and sustainable growth across all states.

UPPCS Notes brings Prelims and Mains programs for UPPCS Prelims and UPPCS Mains Exam preparation. Various Programs initiated by UPPCS Notes are as follows:-

For any doubt, Just leave us a Chat or Fill us a querry––